Approach0:35
Over water from 150 to 200 yards: carry it or play safe?
Golfers who shoot around 100 hit the green 18 percent of the time from 150 to 200 yards in Broadie and Ko's data. Mid handicappers in Broadie's Golfmetrics data average 4.1 awful shots a round, and those cost 4.7 shots. Play to the dry side.
The takeaway
When the green is that unlikely, play to the dry side and trust your chip.
Transcript
150 to 200 yards out, water in front. Carry it, or play safe? Mark Broadie and Soonmin Ko tracked golfers who shoot around 100. They hit the green just 18 percent of the time.
On this hole, a short miss is wet. Mid handicappers in Broadie's data average 4.1 awful shots a round, like balls in the water, and lose 4.7 shots to them. He says some could come from a strategy that's too risky. When the green is that unlikely, play to the dry side.
Sources
- A Simulation Model to Analyze the Impact of Distance and Direction on Golf Scores (opens in new tab). Mark Broadie and Soonmin Ko, Proceedings of the 2009 Winter Simulation Conference, 2009.Data: Golfmetrics amateur rounds scoring 96 to 107 (the 100-golfer group), from a database of 55,000 shots, 2005 to 2009. Figures from Table 2.
- Assessing Golfer Performance Using Golfmetrics (opens in new tab). Mark Broadie, Science and Golf V: World Scientific Congress of Golf, 2008.Data: Middle-handicap amateurs scoring 84 to 97 in the Golfmetrics database (almost 40,000 shots, about 500 rounds, over 130 golfers, mostly 2005 to 2007). Figures from Table 3.



